Wednesday, August 9, 2017

Spider-Man: Homecoming Review

Spider-Man: Homecoming faced high expectations-- not only was it a third interpretation of the character and a sixth in the long line of Spider-Man movies, it was also a Marvel Cinematic Universe installment. Not to mention it had the lowest budget of the Spidey films since Spider-Man in 2002. Was Homecoming everything fans had wanted and more? 

Homecoming centered on Peter Parker's quest to prove himself to Mr. Stark, fit in with his classmates, balance superhero responsibilities with school and life, and win the affection of his crush, Liz. It introduced Vulture to the big screen-- a ex-construction worker who feels cheated by "big shots" like Tony Stark and turns to illegal weapon manufacturing to support himself and his family.

Let's be real, Homecoming lacked the depth we've come to appreciate after the three(yes, all three) Sam Raimi movies. I never really identified a takeaway. The movie played on the concept of Peter's identity with and without the suit. That was great and created a nice little character arc, but was ultimately underplayed. It even toyed with the "With Great Power Comes Great Responsibility" theme that was central in former Spider-Man movies and comics(and many other superhero flicks), but not majorly.

from Amazing Fantasy #15, Spider-Man's debut

This could be attributable to its attempt to cater to a younger audience. The first two acts felt almost like one of those kids movies that's frosted over with innuendo-winks at adults. Some depth could have made it more adult-friendly-- because sorry, that Ned-in-the-library joke doesn't count.

Some of the jokes worked really well, others were crude, out-of-place...or just not funny. Also the instances of strong language were mostly throw-aways and further confused who the film wanted the audience to be.

(From here on, there will be unmarked spoilers. If you haven't seen Homecoming yet, stay clear.)

Michelle delivered some of the funniest lines, but her character felt more like an excuse to include a kids' celebrity-- Zendaya-- until this part. Whether she can justify her inclusion to the series in the next movie, we'll have to see. Flash, who likewise provided a dose of humor, failed to impress the audience as a formidable bully. Even Ned(who was also hilarious) lacked development. Besides Peter and The Vulture, none of the characters experienced much growth or got a chance to emotionally connect with the audience unless by extension because they were friends with/enemies to Peter.

Having got that out of the way, Homecoming was actually an excellent movie. It stood out from other MCU installments and previous Spider-Man movies.

Firstly, Tom Holland plays a basically perfect Spider-Man character. Andrew Garfield may still be a better representation of the original comic book character, but Tom Holland isn't far off. He's definitely less prideful than Garfield's interpretation and less goody-goody than Tobey Maguire-- who, to be fair, is another excellent Peter Parker. Neither Garfield nor Maguire played very convincing teenagers but thankfully Holland nails the fifteen year-old. His character also lends more continuity between Peter and Spidey.

The Vulture wasn't quite as fleshed out as he could have been but was nonetheless one of the best MCU villains since Loki.

I did mention earlier that some of the jokes didn't work-- that being said, this is, hands down, the funniest Spider-Man(and perhaps MCU?) movie ever. In fact, a lot of it was flat out hilarious.

"As you know, we made it out alive, and that’s the important thing. Couldn’t bear to lose a student on a school trip...not again."
-Mr. Harrington on the Washington Monument incident
One of the funniest elements was the insight into everyday life for teenagers in the same universe as the Avengers and their activity. The Captain America PSAs and Flash's Black Widow reference played out perfectly. I don't know why the "hot Aunt May" change was necessary except to mix things up but it provided some of the movie's funniest lines("I think he larbs you.") and otherwise seemed to work.

Thankfully, funny as the movie was, the jokes didn't clog its emotional appeal. A few days before Homecoming, I had watched the popular video, What Writers Should Learn From Wonder Woman, that argues recent Hollywood movies(especially from the MCU) have inadvertently become parodies-- undermining their own emotional appeal by opting for jokes. It's an excellent video; I highly recommend it. While watching Homecoming, I kept an eye out for instances of this mistake. There really aren't any. When Peter loses his suit, when he's on the car ride to homecoming(which has its own sort of nervous humor that isn't what I'm describing), when he decides not to move into the Avengers tower, and above all, when he's caught under the rubble, the audience is allowed to fully experience the consequential emotions.

The rubble scene was one of the too few times in MCU history that I was caught off by my own emotional response. Not only that, it was possibly the most heart wrenching "kid" moment in the entire Spider-Man cinematic history. For the first few lines of his monologue, Peter was a fifteen year old caught under a collapsed building. We have plenty of Peter-Parker-crying shots during Uncle Ben's death or whatnot from the previous franchises but this was a kid dying under a cement heap and he did what any teenager would do-- he freaked out. And it was absolutely effective. It was a jarring reminder to the audience of what previous Spidey series have told us, but never shown us this well.

And let's not forget the plot twist. I'm going to be honest-- at first the reveal failed to impress me. I think I can trace that back to watching Beyond the Mask and its plot twist which followed a similar formula. "Guy likes girl. Guy asks girl out(in this movie he actually proposes). Guy must meet family member first. Family member turns out to be guy's archenemy. Some awkward tension with guy, archenemy, and unwitting girl. Guy and archenemy fight."

But when I had time to reflect on the execution of Homecoming's twist and see it a second time I realized how brilliantly it was executed, especially compared to Beyond the Mask's reveal which was executed lazily.

Not just the twist, but the whole subsequent scene was genius. It was even funny at times but in a way that didn't necessarily compete with the suspenseful tension.

Peter could act immature and even (dare I say?) a little annoying in the beginning of the movie, but once the Vulture reveal scene triggered his leaving homecoming, saving Adrian's life, and finally turning down Tony Stark's offer, we were given gobs of reason to get behind him and sympathize with him. By the end, the audience was ready to shout with the ferry passenger, "Yeah, Spider-Man!" Or I was anyway.

As to the ending before the end credits, I'm personally really looking forward to seeing how Aunt May interacts with this discovery and his future superhero activity.

The first end credit scene touchingly completed The Vulture's character arc and the second end credit scene...well, that scene speaks for itself.

In conclusion, Spider-Man: Homecoming introduces fresh content to the MCU and legacy of Spider-Man movies. Despite lacking the depth Sam Raimi taught us superhero movies are capable of, it delivers an emotionally compelling and otherwise highly entertaining reincarnation of one of Marvel's most iconic superheroes. I loved it, it was amazing, and I'm giving it a solid 4 out of 5 stars.

What did you think about Spider-Man: Homecoming? What did you think was the takeaway of the movie? What has been your favorite Spider-Man movie thus far? 


  1. I enjoyed your review, and I do agree with you on most points. You have a great way of writing a review, it's very interesting to read! Thankfully I was able to read your entire post and not worry about spoilers, seeing as how I've seen the movie. :D
    Thank you for the post!

    1. Thank you! Aww, I really appreciate that. :)

      Yes, that does help! I could have opted to make it spoiler-free but the spoilers are some of the best parts! Besides everyone should just go and see it. xD

      Thank you for commenting!